After Liverpool left, Jurgen Klopp’s Replay Called It Even More Poisonous
Jurgen Klopp knew exactly what he was doing when he ordered a repeat of Liverpool’s match against Tottenham Hotspur in October.
This was not a sarcastic jab delivered in the midst of feeling defeated by a contender for the title.
Klopp went above and beyond what was anticipated when the complete absurdity of what had happened between referees—including how video assistants misled the official and denied Liverpool a goal—emerged a few days later.
He told the reporters, “Some people probably don’t want me to say, but as a football person, more so than as Liverpool’s manager, the only outcome should be a replay.”
That’s the reality. It is unlikely to occur.
“As significant and influential as football is, it is imperative that we handle it appropriately.
“That was not intentional on the part of any of the parties involved, including the on-field referee, linesman, fourth official, and, in this instance, VAR.
“I believe there would have been after-the-fact solutions for that evident error.”
The response seemed intense at the time; so intense, in fact, that former Liverpool manager Graeme Souness thought it was more of a motivational ploy than a sincere recommendation.
He stated in the Daily Mail, “I did not agree with Jurgen Klopp coming out to say he wanted last weekend’s game replayed.”
“Where does everything end up? When someone feels wronged, everyone will want the same thing. It ushers in a twelve-month season.
“Jurgen undoubtedly knows full well that there’s little chance of it occurring, but asking for a rematch isn’t really about getting one. He’s now taking full use of the chance to inspire that bunch of guys. use their sense of injustice for the benefit of the team.
The scenario around Klopp has significantly changed since Souness’s appraisal of his behavior; the manager has declared he will be leaving the team at the end of the current campaign.
The crucial call that broke the news to Liverpool’s owners was made in November, one month after the replay demand was made, it has since come to light.
So the real question is, when he made such a drastic demand, how much of that desire to go was there in his mind?
It’s crucial background information because Klopp and Liverpool’s aggressive attack on the refereeing has long-lasting effects.
If his request for a response had been made alone, it would have been simple to ignore it, but it was made in reaction to an unprecedented official club statement that said the incorrect call was made due to “significant human error” and was sent to the governing body for authorities.
“Liverpool accepts the Professional Game Match Officials Limited’s (PGMOL) acknowledgement of their shortcomings from last night. It stated, “It is evident that the rules of the game were not correctly applied, undermining sporting integrity.”
This is critical for the validity of decision-making in the future because it affects all clubs and lessons are being applied to enhance procedures so that a situation like this one won’t happen again.
“In the meantime, we will explore the range of options available, given the clear need for escalation and resolution.”
After considering Liverpool’s remarks, which would almost definitely need Klopp’s approval, former Manchester United defender turned analyst Gary Neville called the declaration inaccurate.
“Discuss about examining all options—what does that really mean?!” and athletic integrity are risky expressions in addition to being ambiguous and hostile,” he posted on social media site X.
Neville is correct in saying that using these phrases to escalate the argument taints conversations regarding officiating calls after games and pushes ridiculous fringe aspects of the sport into the mainstream.
The consequences of Klopp and Liverpool’s words have already begun to be felt.
Just as the German manager was supposedly picking up the phone to Fenway Sports Group to inform them he’d be leaving at the end of the season, title rivals Arsenal were on the other end of a controversial decision against Newcastle United.
Although far less egregious than the call made against Liverpool, Arsenal felt aggrieved that the winning goal against them had been allowed to stand despite a triple check by VAR on the ball going out of play, a foul on a defender and an offside.
In the aftermath, manager Mikel Arteta lambasted the decision, stating: “You have to talk about how the hell did this goal stand up? Incredible. I feel embarrassed. I have to now come in here and try to defend the club and please ask for help, because it’s an absolute disgrace that this goal is allowed. An absolute disgrace.”
What followed demonstrated how the Liverpool reaction has shifted the parameters.
In the days after, Arsenal also released a club statement “wholeheartedly” supporting the manager’s comments and attacking the refereeing body.
“The Premier League is the best league in the world with the best players, coaches and supporters, all of whom deserve better,” read the statement.
“PGMOL urgently needs to address the standard of officiating and focus on action which moves us all on from retrospective analysis, attempted explanations and apologies.”
Thankfully there have been no further decisions against clubs at the top of the table so the escalating fury has subsided.
But make no mistake, the debate has been poisoned, clubs now feel emboldened to publicly criticize the referees and their governing bodies.
If there is another big controversial call in the title run-in you can only imagine the reaction.
It seems unlikely Klopp would not be aware of that when he made his remarks.
Only he knows what was running through his head at the time and to what extent he was thinking about his time in the league coming to a close.
But it’s sad if there was even the hint he might be departing that he’d willingly act in a reckless manner that will affect those after him.
One thing is clear, English soccer will live with the consequences of his words from now on.
Leave a Reply